Demographics and Interest Rates

In my opinion, economists discount the importance of demographics. For example, here is a graph of the ratio of the 15-39 population and the 40+ population and 10-year interest rates. Pretty clear pattern. Why?

It’s all about demand and supply of capital. When we are young, we demand capital. We go to college (student loans). We buy a car (car loan). We buy houses (Mortgages). We start businesses (bank loans, PE). We unfortunately get into credit card debt. All of these demand capital.

When we are older, we pay off student loans, car loans, mortgages. We cash out of our businesses. And we start to invest so we have money to retire. In other words, we are suppliers of captital.

So when this ratio is high, there is high demand for capital, but low relative supply. What happens when demand is high and supply is low? Price goes up. In this case, price is interest rates.

When the opposite happens – like now – and the demand is low relative to supply, the price goes down and we have low interest rates.

This ratio is going to continue to decline over the coming decades. In 2040 for example, it should only be 0.58 compared to about 0.7 today. Thus, the expectation is that interest rates will continue to sink over the next few decades.

If Bitcoin is the New Gold, Is That a Good Thing?

Bitcoin is supposedly “digital” gold. Let’s say I concede this is true…. is that a good thing? In 1971, the US went off the gold standard and by 1980 gold went from $35* to $600+. Let’s see how that compares to Bitcoin.

The rally in bitcoin has been far, far higher in terms of percent but the overall look is pretty similar if we line up today with 1980.

The problem? After 1980, it took 26 years – 26 (!) years – to get back to $600 an ounce. In fact, since 1980, the total returns for gold, T-bonds, Corporate bonds, and Stocks has been:

  • Inflation: 215%
  • Gold: 177%
  • T-Bonds: 1831%
  • Corporates: 4406%
  • Stocks: 9744%

See the problem with Gold (and Bitcoin) is that there is no REAL return. If you buy an ounce of gold or a bitcoin today, in 100 years… you have an ounce of gold and a bitcoin. Yes, they can potentially protect you from inflation… but that’s it.

I’m not sure if this is 1980 for Bitcoin. Things can get more crazy than you think. And Financial assets have enjoyed lower rates over this time period. But it still doesn’t change the fact that Gold (and Bitcoin) in the long-term guarantee you no real rate of return.